Republicans and Democrats on Monday used Tax Day to drive home their arguments about President TrumpDonald John Trump2020 Dem hits back at Trump for giving ‘firefighting advice’ to Paris: ‘Do your own damn job’ French officials reject Trump suggestion to use ‘flying water tankers’ on Notre Dame fire Overnight Energy: Interior watchdog opens investigation into new secretary | Warren unveils 2020 plan to stop drilling on public lands | Justices reject case challenging state nuclear subsidies | Court orders EPA to re-evaluate Obama pollution rule MORE’s 2017 law, as millions more Americans are poised to soon find out whether they personally benefited from the tax overhaul.
Trump and Republicans spent the day praising their tax-code rewrite and linked it to growth in the economy and wages.
ADVERTISEMENT
“We promised that these tax cuts would be rocket fuel for the American economy, and we were absolutely right,” Trump said at a roundtable with business owners and employees in Burnsville, Minn.
Democrats, meanwhile, argued that the law has been more beneficial for corporations than for American workers. They highlighted their own tax proposals and pressed the IRS to comply with a formal request from House Democrats for six years of Trump’s tax returns.
“On this Tax Day, big banks, big pharma and big corporations are celebrating their record windfall and soaring profits from the GOP Tax Scam for the rich,” Speaker Nancy PelosiNancy Patricia D'Alesandro PelosiPaul Ryan joins University of Notre Dame faculty Dems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day Dems rally behind Omar as Trump escalates attacks MORE (D-Calif.) said in a statement. “Yet, for millions of hard-working families, Tax Day is not living up to the Republicans’ promises.”
The legislation Trump signed into law in December 2017 marked the president’s biggest legislative accomplishment at the time. Much of the law’s changes took effect in 2018, meaning this year is the first time tax returns will reflect many of the new changes.
Analysts across the ideological spectrum have estimated that most taxpayers are receiving a tax cut for 2018, due to lower tax rates and a larger standard deduction. But polls show that the law lacks widespread public support, with few people saying they paid less in taxes compared to previous years.
Almost every Republican who was in Congress in 2017 voted for the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, while every Democrat voted against it. The two sides spent much of the last year sparring over whether the law has been helpful to people.
ADVERTISEMENT
The fight over the law was reignited Monday because April 15 is the deadline in most states for people to file their tax returns. The renewed message battle over the law also comes as the 2020 presidential election heats up.
In Trump’s visit to Minnesota, he touted various provisions of the law, such as the larger standard deduction, repeal of ObamaCare’s individual mandate and reduction in the number of estates subject to the estate tax.
“We’re getting historic tax relief,” he said.
Trump administration officials and GOP lawmakers also touted the tax law in television appearances and op-eds.
“It’s great to celebrate Tax Day for the first time when people’s taxes are going down,“ Treasury Secretary Steven MnuchinSteven Terner MnuchinDems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day Pro-trade groups slam Trump tariffs on Tax Day The Hill’s 12:30 Report: Washington braces for Mueller report MORE said on Fox Business Network, adding that “there’s no question we’re seeing the impact and the benefit this has had on the economy.”
Key business groups that support the tax law highlighted how their members have used their savings from the law to invest in new equipment and hire more workers.
“We have a lot of great examples of companies that credit the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act for their continued growth,” said Ashley Wilson, who leads tax legislative strategy at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.
While Republicans have been praising the measure, Democrats have been attacking it as a giveaway for wealthy individuals and corporations. Estimates have found that households in all income groups, on average, are getting a tax cut, but that higher-income households are getting the largest increases in their after-tax incomes.
Some of the Democrats’ focus has been on how corporations have announced billions in stock buybacks since the tax law was enacted. Additionally, in some cases, Democrats are arguing that middle-class taxpayers are seeing higher taxes and lower refunds as a result of the law.
Only a small percentage of taxpayers are estimated to get a tax increase, and IRS data shows that refund amounts through April 5 are on average about the same as last year.
The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) launched Facebook ads in 12 House districts to attack Republican lawmakers for their votes for the law.
“Voters sent a message when they booted Republicans out of the Majority last November, and today their message is the same, ‘thanks for nothing,’” DCCC spokesperson Cole Leiter said.
Democrats are also offering proposals focused on cutting taxes for the middle class, trying to draw a contrast between themselves and Republicans on taxes.
Sen. Cory BookerCory Anthony BookerDems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day Overnight Health Care: How 2020 Dems want to overhaul health care | Brooklyn parents sue over measles vaccination mandate | Measles outbreak nears record On The Money: Five things to watch on first Tax Day under Trump’s law | Trump lawyer disputes Dem reasons for requesting tax returns | Trump struggles to reshape Fed MORE (D-N.J.), who is running for president, rolled out a plan on Monday to expand the earned income tax credit, which benefits low- and middle-income taxpayers. His proposal comes after Senate Democrats offered legislation last week to expand the earned income tax credit and the child tax credit.
“Creating a fairer, more just tax code begins with putting money in the pockets of Americans who are struggling to get ahead,” Booker said in a statement.
Much of the Tax Day messaging by Democrats focused on the issue of Trump’s tax returns.
Several Democratic presidential candidates have been releasing their returns over the past several days, in an effort to contrast themselves with Trump — the first president in decades not to make any of his tax returns public.
Sen. Kamala HarrisKamala Devi HarrisSanders town hall audience cheers after Fox News host asks if they’d support ‘Medicare for All’ Dems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day O’Rourke releases 10 years of tax returns MORE (D-Calif.) released 15 years of her tax returns on Sunday, and Sen. Amy KlobucharAmy Jean KlobucharDems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day O’Rourke releases 10 years of tax returns Bernie Sanders releases 10 years of tax returns MORE (D-Minn.) recently released her 2018 tax return after previously making public filings from earlier years.
Sen. Bernie SandersBernard (Bernie) SandersSanders town hall audience cheers after Fox News host asks if they’d support ‘Medicare for All’ Sanders defends against criticism over income, taxes Sanders on whether he’s too old to be president: ‘Follow me around the campaign trail’ MORE (I-Vt.) on Monday released 10 years of his returns, as did former Rep. Beto O’RourkeRobert (Beto) Francis O’RourkeDems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day O’Rourke releases 10 years of tax returns Bernie Sanders releases 10 years of tax returns MORE (D-Texas).
Democrats also pressed the Trump administration to comply with a request made by House Ways and Means Commissioner Richard NealRichard Edmund NealDems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day On The Money: Five things to watch on first Tax Day under Trump’s law | Trump lawyer disputes Dem reasons for requesting tax returns | Trump struggles to reshape Fed Trump lawyer disputes Dem rationale for requesting tax returns MORE (D-Mass.) for the IRS to provide his panel with Trump’s tax returns.
Several liberal groups and Democratic lawmakers urged the administration to follow Neal’s request, in a call with reporters on Monday. Progressive groups also held a rally outside IRS headquarters in Washington, bringing with them a giant chicken that resembles Trump.
“I want to know if the president is paying his fair share,” Rep. Bill PascrellWilliam (Bill) James PascrellDems, Trump harden 2020 battle lines on Tax Day Trump lawyer disputes Dem rationale for requesting tax returns Fight escalates over Trump’s tax returns MORE (D-N.J.), a Ways and Means Committee member, told reporters.