Dan Girardi the odd man out in Rangers’ defense conundrum

Dan Girardi the odd man out in Rangers’ defense conundrum

ANAHEIM, Calif. — So the first domino fell in the Rangers’ seven-defensemen-into-six-slots quandary and it was Dan Girardi sitting out to accommodate Kevin Klein’s return to the lineup for Sunday’s 6-3 defeat to the Ducks.

Coach Alain Vigneault’s decision seemed to be based as much on the blue-line unit’s performance in Saturday’s 3-0 victory in Los Angles as it was on the demands of going back-to-back with Girardi, who had been sidelined for 12 games tending to an ankle injury prior to making his re-entry against the Kings as Ryan McDonagh’s first-pair partner.

“If you look at Saturday night’s game, both Danny and Ryan spent a lot of time in our own end, if you look at our puck possession numbers when they were on the ice,” said Vigneault, who inserted Klein into Girardi’s spot on McDonagh’s right side. “That pair got caught out quite a bit in our own end. This seemed like the smarter way to go.”

According to NaturalStattrick.com, the Rangers were out-attempted 60-32 during five-on-five play and 31-11 in the second period. McDonagh was minus-30 (8/38) and Girardi minus-27 (9/36) while Skjei and Smith were each plus-five (12/7 apiece) and Staal (12/18) and Holden were each minus-six.

Vigneault did allow that the back-to-back mitigated against Girardi dressing for this one.

“As I had said, I didn’t want to put two injured defensemen in at the same time,” Vigneault said in reference to veteran righties Girardi and Klein, the latter of whom had missed 15 straight since leaving the lineup with back issues on Feb. 23. “Obviously it is not an easy situation for Danny with that type of injury where he didn’t skate much or do a lot of off-ice conditioning.

“Kleiner is in and we’ll go from there.”

Girardi got 20:03 of ice time Saturday while paired with McDonagh, including a pair of extended shifts during which the Blueshirts were pinned in their own zone.

“I knew it wasn’t going to be perfect, but I just tried to go out there, work hard, block some shots and make some hits, just try to do whatever,” Girardi said after the match. “I was on for a couple of marathon shifts, that didn’t help the breathing out there too much, but I felt like, we were all trying to make plays out there and had good sticks out there and I think for the most part we stuck with it.”

Klein played 20:10 while paired with McDonagh for the fourth time this season. The tandem had been intact for three straight on Dec. 28, Dec. 29 and Jan. 3. Klein was a plus-four Corsi (18/14) against the Ducks at five-on-five while McDonagh was minus two (15/17).

Suffice to say it is unlikely that Klein will be sitting Tuesday in San Jose.


The Rangers’ power-play goal against the Kings originally credited to McDonagh is expected to be officially changed on Monday to Mika Zibanejad, who deflected the puck past J onathan Quick. That would mean two goals in the last 14 games for No. 93.